Community service for farmer's polluting dam of manure
Farmer Derek Dyer contaminated a private water supply and polluted a stream after a slurry store built from farmyard manure collapsed.
Aerial view of Dyer illegal slurry store. Credit: Environment Agency.
Dyer, aged 74, of Crawley Farm, Yarcombe near Honiton, received a community order of 60 hours unpaid work and was ordered to pay total costs of £15,388.40 and surcharge of £114 by District Judge Smith at Exeter magistrates last Thursday.
He admitted one charge of causing pollution and two charges related to the construction of an illegal slurry store at a field off Greenway Lane, Clayhanger, Combe St Nicholas, near Chard.
In a case brought by the Environment Agency, the court heard that Agency officers went to the field in January 2023 following several reports of pollution in a tributary of the River Isle. The pollution was traced to a large structure made from farmyard manure which had been constructed to store slurry. Part of one of the walls had collapsed resulting in the entire store contents pouring out and causing widespread contamination and damage.
The slurry flowed across two fields and down the hillside into a wooded area. The volume of slurry was such that it left behind a “track” up to 20m wide in places and the force was such that two wire fences were damaged. The tideline left on fence posts indicated a depth of 12 inches of slurry flowing into a wooded area over 400m from the store location.
Dyer slurry pollution through local woodland. Credit: Environment Agency.
Extensive contamination occurred within the wooded area where springs supply drinking water for several properties on the Chilworthy Estate. The Estate provided bottled drinking water to all residents as soon as they became aware of the potential pollution of their water supply, Water samples of the drinking supply later confirmed elevated levels of E.coli and total coliforms above drinking water standards.
A wild swimming pond at a nearby glamping site had also been polluted with slurry.
In a statement submitted to the Environment Agency, Derek Dyer admitted that he and his son had used the rented field for the store because they did not have sufficient slurry storage and that an application for a new store had been delayed by the Local Planning Authority. He expressed regret for what happened, believing the makeshift store would hold up slurry until it could be spread, but claimed the heavy rain had caused it to collapse.
Summing up, District Judge Smith described the act of building a slurry store from farmyard manure as reckless, and concluded that Dyer, with all his years of experience, should have known better.
Following the court hearing, Dave Womack of the Environment Agency said:
In over 30 years of regulating farms I have never seen such extensive contamination by slurry. Mr Dyer showed a flagrant disregard of the law. Regulations which prescribe how to construct slurry stores have been in place since 1991 and all farmers need to follow some basic requirements to prevent catastrophic events like this from happening.
If farmers are concerned about the storage capacity of existing facilities, we would advise that they contact their local Environment Agency office and discuss proposals to ensure the environment is properly protected and valuable nutrient resources aren’t wasted.
Notes to editors
The charges:
-
On and after the 13 January 2023, you did cause an unpermitted water discharge activity, namely the discharge of poisonous, noxious or polluting matter from Chilworthy Field, off Greenway Lane, Combe St Nicholas, Chard, Somerset, into inland fresh waters, contrary to Regulations 12(1)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(a) of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016.
-
On or before the 13 January 2023 at Chilworthy Field, off Greenway Lane, Combe St Nicholas, Chard, Somerset, you failed to ensure that slurry was stored in accordance with Regulation 4(1) of the Water Resources (Control of Pollution) (Silage, Slurry and Agricultural Fuel Oil) (England) Regulations 2010, contrary to Regulation 10(1) of the Water Resources (Control of Pollution) (Silage, Slurry and Agricultural Fuel Oil) (England) Regulations 2010.
-
On or before the 13 January 2023 at Chilworthy Field, off Greenway Lane, Combe St Nicholas, Chard, Somerset, you failed to notify the Environment Agency of the construction, substantial enlargement, or substantial reconstruction of a slurry storage area in accordance with Regulation (9) of the Water Resources (Control of Pollution) (Silage, Slurry and Agricultural Fuel Oil) (England) Regulations 2010, contrary to Regulation 10(2) of the Water Resources (Control of Pollution) (Silage, Slurry and Agricultural Fuel Oil) (England) Regulations 2010.