CH202050 - How to do a compliance check: compliance check series of factsheets: when to issue factsheets
You should issue the appropriate factsheet(s) in all these circumstances.
At the start of the compliance check
You ask the customer to send you electronic records
You issue an information notice
You write to notify a visit or inspection
You ask for evidence of behaviour
You are considering suspending a penalty
You are asked for more information about appeals
At the start of the compliance check
1. Issue one of these factsheets.
CC/FS1a - General information about compliance checks
CC/FS1b - General information about compliance checks by Compliance Centres
CC/FS1c - General information about compliance checks into certain large and complex businesses
CC/FS1d - General information about compliance checks into Excise matters
CC/FS1f - General information about compliance checks into tax advantaged share schemes
CC/FS1g - General information about compliance checks into customs and international trade matters
These factsheets tell the customer
- what a compliance check is and what to expect
- about their rights
- about the advantages of disclosing any known
- inaccuracies
- failures to notify
- wrongdoings
- deliberate withholding of information
- where they can find information about the Human Rights Act
2. If you suspect fraud at this stage, consider the Suspected Fraud Identification Process, see CH290000. If the referral is not adopted and returned to you to continue your enquiry you should then consider issuing factsheet CC/FS9 The Human Rights Act and penalties and the relevant penalty factsheet from the list below in
3. For teams issuing OED letters – if you have robust information indicating something is wrong with the return or claim (Category 1 or 2 at CH206250) then issue CC/FS9 with the opening OED letter.
You ask the customer to send you electronic records
You should send factsheet CC/FS22 Sending us electronic records
- with your ‘opening letter’ if you are asking for electronic records at the start of the check, or
- when you ask for electronic records to be sent to you at any other stage during the check.
This factsheet explains to the customer
- what we mean by electronic records
- what happens if we ask them to send electronic records to us during a compliance check
You issue an information notice
Factsheet CC/FS2 Information notices tells the person:
- what an information notice is
- when we use them
- about their rights
You must only issue factsheet CC/FS2 when you are issuing an information notice under FA08/Sch36, see CH221000.
You must not issue factsheet CC/FS2 if:
- you are requesting information without issuing a formal information notice
- you are using Excise powers under CEMA79. The factsheet to use when carrying out checks under CEMA79 is factsheet CC/FS16 Excise visits.
You write to notify a visit or inspection
Factsheet CC/FS3 Visits - by agreement or with advance notice tells the person:
- why we visit business premises
- about the visit
- about their rights
You must issue a copy of factsheet CC/FS3 when you write to tell the person that you intend to visit them, see CH253000.
You must not use factsheet CC/FS3 if:
- you are carrying out an unannounced inspection. Instead you must use one of the factsheets in 'You visit unannounced' below
- you are using Excise powers under CEMA79. The factsheet to use when carrying out checks under CEMA79 is factsheet CC/FS16 Excise visits.
You visit unannounced
Factsheet CC/FS4 Unannounced visits for inspections tells the person:
- why we make unannounced visits
- about their rights
You must also serve the person with a Notice of Inspection.
If the unannounced visit is at the start of the compliance check you must also issue the appropriate general information factsheet from the list in 'At the start of the compliance check' above.
You must not use factsheet CC/FS4 when carrying out an Excise visit using powers under CEMA79. Instead, use factsheet CC/FS16 Excise visits.
If you undertake a tribunal approved unannounced visit to carry out an inspection you must issue factsheet CC/FS5 Unannounced visits for inspections approved by the tribunal.
Factsheet CC/FS5 tells the person:
- that the visit has been authorised by a tribunal
- about the penalties we can charge if they refuse entry
- about their rights
You ask for evidence of behaviour
Remember, if you suspect fraud you must consider the Suspected Fraud Identification Process, see CH290000 before you ask for evidence of behaviour.
In all cases where there is an inaccuracy, under-assessment, failure to notify or VAT or excise wrongdoing, you need evidence to enable you to make a penalty decision. Unless you already have evidence that the non-compliance was a mistake despite taking reasonable care or a non-deliberate failure, you need to ask the customer about how the non-compliance happened in order to gather the evidence. Before you do this you must explain to them their right not to self-incriminate and issue them with factsheet CC/FS9 The Human Rights Act and penalties.
You should also give them the factsheet on the penalty or penalties that may be charged.
CC/FS7a Penalties for inaccuracies in returns or documents
CC/FS7b Penalties for not telling us about an under-assessment
CC/FS11 Penalties for failure to notify
CC/FS12 Penalties for VAT and Excise wrongdoing
CC/FS15 Self Assessment and old penalty rules
CC/FS17 Higher penalties for Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax involving offshore matters
CC/FS18a Penalties for failure to file returns on time – Income tax and Capital Gains Tax
CC/FS18b Penalties for failure to file returns on time – Construction Industry Scheme (CIS)
CC/FS18c Penalties for failure to file returns on time – Machine Games Duty
CC/FS19 Employer and contractor returns and ‘old’ penalty rules
CC/FS20 VAT dishonest conduct penalties
If you think that a penalty for deliberate behaviour or civil evasion might be payable, you should also issue factsheet CC/FS14 Managing Serious Defaulters at this time.
You are considering suspending a penalty
Factsheet CC/FS10 Suspending penalties for careless inaccuracies in returns or documents tells the person:
- when we can suspend a penalty
- when we cannot or will not suspend a penalty
- about setting suspension conditions and the period of suspension
- about what happens at the end of the suspension period
- about their rights
You must issue factsheet CC/FS10 when you have established that there is a careless inaccuracy, even if you do not believe it will be possible to set SMART conditions. Do not wait until you issue the NPPS100 Penalty Explanation letter before you issue factsheet CC/FS10.
CH83130 explains when a penalty may be suspended.
PDDD applies
Remember, if you suspect fraud during your compliance check you must consider the Suspected Fraud Identification Process, see CH290000 before you consider issuing CC/FS13.
Factsheet CC/FS13 Publishing Details of Deliberate Defaulters (PDDD) tells the person:
- why we publish details of deliberate defaulters
- how to avoid having their details published
- how we decide whether to publish their details
- what information we can publish
- where and for how long we will publish their details
- about their rights
You should issue factsheet CC/FS13 as soon as you have an evidence-based reason to believe that:
- there is a deliberate inaccuracy, failure to notify or VAT or Excise wrongdoing and
- the PLR may exceed £25,000.
In certain circumstances it will be appropriate to issue factsheet CC/FS13 at the start of a compliance check, for example, a person makes a disclosure of a deliberate inaccuracy, failure to notify or VAT or Excise wrongdoing before or at the start of a compliance check and the PLR may exceed £25,000, see CH500500.
There is a dispute
You should issue factsheet CC/FS21 Alternative Dispute Resolution if:
- the person asks for it, or
- the ADR team has agreed that it is appropriate to invite the customer to apply for ADR.
For further guidance on ADR, see CH280400.
Factsheet CC/FS21 explains:
- how Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) can be used to resolve a dispute during a compliance check
- what types of dispute are suitable for ADR
- how to apply for ADR
You are asked for more information about appeals
You must only issue HMRC1 if the person:
- asks for it or
- asks for information about appeals and reviews
In most cases we would normally direct the customer to the Gov.uk website to find the HMRC1 for themselves so they can review it and print it where required.
Do not routinely issue HMRC1 with decision notices.
HMRC1 HM Revenue & Customs decisions – what to do if you disagree explains what a person can do if they do not agree with a decision they can appeal against. This includes details of how to ask for a review and how to appeal to the independent tribunal.